Semantic Search vs Keyword Search: What You Need to Know

In the ever-evolving world of search engines and digital content, understanding how search mechanisms operate is crucial for businesses aiming to improve their online presence. These two prominent search methodologies play significant roles in shaping user experience in ecommerce and search engine optimization (SEO) strategies. This article dives deep into these search approaches, highlighting their differences, benefits, limitations, and real-world applications, particularly focusing on the semantic search vs keyword search technologies.

What is Semantic Search?

Semantic search refers to the use of artificial intelligence (AI), natural language processing (NLP), and machine learning (ML) to improve the understanding of a user’s search intent and the contextual meaning behind queries. A semantic search engine aims to grasp the meaning and intent behind user queries, moving beyond simple keyword matching. Unlike a traditional search engine, a semantic search engine deciphers relationships between words and how they fit within a broader context. This approach allows search engines to deliver more accurate and relevant results. Here's an example:

Semantic search engines understand that the intent behind searching for 'cheap laptop' is to find a mobile, laptop-sized device that costs less than 500 USD. In contrast, keyword-based search will only focus on items explicitly labeled as a laptop and may prioritize products with the word 'cheap' in their descriptions, potentially improving their ranking. However, it will also return all laptops, regardless of price.

How Semantic Search Works

A semantic search engine  uses advanced tools like Natural Language Processing or NLP that helps computers understand human language by interpreting meaning, context, and intent behind words, allowing more accurate responses to queries.

It also utilizes technology that turns words into numbers that capture their meaning and finding the best matches for your search intent (Vector Search).

Machine Learning or ML, enables computers to learn from data and improve over time by recognizing patterns and making predictions, helping provide smarter and more relevant search results. Machine learning algorithms can also learn from key performance indicators. Machine learning can help boost user satisfaction by providing relevant results as well.

For example, if a user queries “What is semantic search?“ the search engine uses NLP to comprehend that the user seeks a definition or explanation of the term, returning results that satisfy that intent.

Semantic Search Examples

Understanding the meaning and intent behind search queries is crucial in semantic search, as it improves user experience by enabling search engines to interpret vague or concept-based queries more effectively.

Semantic search shines in cases where simple keyword matches fail to capture the user’s real intent. Semantic search work involves interpreting user queries to deliver more relevant and contextually accurate results.Consider these examples:

• Voice search: When a user asks, “Where is the best Italian restaurant nearby?” semantic search uses location data and contextual clues to return results tailored to their specific request.
• E-commerce searches: Typing “running shoes” prompts results for running shoes of the perfect size, and for the perfect activity and color based on previous search data, even if the product descriptions do not explicitly contain those words.

• Song lyrics: Searching for “Hello, it’s me” yields results for Adele’s song “Hello,” showing the engine’s ability to match phrases with content beyond literal keyword matches.

What is Keyword Search?

Keyword search, also called lexical search or traditional search has been the foundation of search engine technology for decades. This method focuses on exact matches of words or phrases within web pages. The search engine indexes pages and matches user queries to documents based on the occurrence and frequency of those keywords.

How it works

In lexical search, the engine uses a list that shows which web pages have certain words. When someone searches for "best running shoes," the engine finds pages with exact match to those words and sorts them based on how often the words appear and how unique they are in the content.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Pros:

• Straightforward and effective for finding documents that contain specific terms.
• Quick implementation and low computational power requirements.
• Transparent results where users can see why a document matched their query.

Cons:

• Limited contextual understanding: Fails to consider synonyms or the overall meaning of queries.
• Prone to irrelevant results: May return documents that contain the search terms without aligning with the user’s intent.
• Easily gamed: Keyword stuffing can sometimes mislead the engine into ranking less relevant content higher.

The Key Differences - Semantic Search Engines vs. Traditional Search Engines

When choosing between semantic search and lexical search, understanding their distinct functionalities is crucial. Semantic search interprets the intent behind search queries by understanding their semantic meaning. Here’s how they differ:

1. Understanding User Intent

Semantic Search: Prioritizes the user’s search intent, using NLP and ML to understand context and related terms. NLP enables computers to understand and process human language, enhancing semantic search capabilities by accounting for the complexities of human language.

Keyword Search: Relies solely on literal matches of the query words, lacking the ability to grasp nuanced meanings.

2. Handling Synonyms and Variations

• Semantic Search: Capable of identifying synonyms and related phrases, ensuring comprehensive, and relevant results.
• Keyword Search: May miss highly relevant search results if they do not contain the exact words typed by the user.

3. Complex Queries and Natural Language Processing

• Semantic Search: Excels at processing natural language queries and ambiguous searches, such as "how do eagles hunt?" which could relate to both bird behavior and metaphorical uses.
• Keyword Search: Struggles with complex queries that do not match specific keyword strings.

4. Relevance and Precision

• Semantic Search: Provides more precise, contextually more relevant search results, improving user experience by delivering search engine results that accurately reflect user intent.
• Lexical Search: Might deliver a high volume of web pages, but their relevance may vary significantly.

Applications and Use Cases

When to Use Keyword Search

This type of search experience remains effective in scenarios where precision is necessary, such as:

• Academic and legal research: Where exact matches are needed.
• Simple product catalogs: For users familiar with specific terms.
• Technical documentation: Where terminology is highly specific.

When to Use Semantic Search

Semantic search is ideal for enhancing user experiences by improving the relevance and accuracy of the search results based on user intent in:

• Customer service portals: Users can search in natural language, improving satisfaction.
• E-commerce platforms: Ensures better product discovery even when descriptions use varied terminology.
• Voice search and virtual assistants: Provides contextually accurate answers to spoken queries.
• Patent searches: Identifies related concepts and prior art even if terminology differs.

Semantic Search vs Keyword Search in E-commerce

For e-commerce businesses, the choice between semantic search and keyword search can directly impact customer experience and sales. E-commerce platforms thrive on providing intuitive, accurate product discovery, and this is where semantic search excels. Unlike a traditional search engine, which may only return exact matches, semantic search is able to understand query intent and synonyms, resulting in a more comprehensive product search experience.

Benefits of using a Semantic Search Engine in E-commerce

1. Enhanced Product Discovery: Users often search using phrases or informal language. For instance, someone looking for "gym sneakers" might find relevant products even if they are labeled "training shoes" or "sports footwear."
2. Improved User Experience: Semantic search adapts to how users phrase their queries naturally, making the search process smoother and more intuitive.
3. Personalization and Relevance: Semantic search can incorporate past search behavior, location, and user preferences, tailoring results to individual users.

Drawbacks of Traditional Search in E-commerce

Lexical search in e-commerce may fail when:

• Synonyms and Variations: A search for "evening dresses" might miss products labeled "gowns" or "formal attire."
• User Frustration: The rigidity of lexical search can lead to user dissatisfaction if exact terms are not used.

Real-World Example: Semantic Search in Action

Imagine an e-commerce platform where a user types "best phone for photography". A semantic search engine can return accurate results including smartphone models known for camera quality, even if the product descriptions do not contain the exact phrase. This level of context-driven search can boost user satisfaction and conversion rates.

Vector Search vs Semantic Search

While discussing semantic search and traditional search, it's also essential to mention vector search.

How Vector Search Works

This type of search maps words and phrases as points in a multi-dimensional space, where the distance between them shows how closely they relate in meaning. This means that when you search for something like "affordable cars," the system identifies content connected to budget-friendly vehicles, even if the exact word "affordable" isn't used. By comparing these points based on their closeness, vector search helps semantic search find results that match the intent and context of your query, not just results with matching keywords. This leads to more relevant and accurate search outcomes. Here's how you can imagine these keywords as points in a multi-dimensional space:

Example: Searching for "kitten" in a vector-based engine would return results about different content related to cats, even if they use phrases like "feline" or "cat" or "kitten" or "tomcat".

Vector-based search is a foundational technology that supports semantic search but doesn’t inherently account for searcher intent or NLP insights.

Semantic search utilizes vector technology but adds layers of contextual analysis and entity recognition. In other words, it better understands the topic and the true intention of the user.

Semantic Search in SEO

The rise of semantic search has redefined the traditional SEO strategy. Unlike keyword-centric SEO, which focuses on exact terms, semantic SEO is about creating detailed web content that covers a topic well, matches what people are really searching for, and fits the meaning behind their searches. This means creating topic-rich content that addresses user needs holistically.

Key SEO Adjustments for Semantic Search

1. Content Depth: Create comprehensive content that covers the main topic and related subtopics to be seen as an authoritative source.
2. Natural Language: Use long-tail keywords and conversational phrases to align with how people naturally search, especially with voice and question-based queries.
3. Entity-Based Content: Focus on important topics and use special coding (called schema) to show how these ideas connect. This helps search engines understand your content better.
4. User Intent Alignment: Addresses the user's query intent (informational, navigational, transactional) to ensure content meets user needs.
5. Content Groups: Group related content together and link them to a main page to show your knowledge and make your website easier to navigate.
6. Readability and On-Page Experience: Make content easy to read with clear formatting and subheadings, aiding user engagement and retention.

Conclusion: Embracing the Future of Search

Choosing between semantic search and keyword search depends on your business needs and the user experience you aim to create. For e-commerce platforms, semantic search enhances product discovery and user engagement by understanding queries more intuitively. In SEO, embracing semantic strategies allows for richer, context-driven content that aligns better with searcher's intent, ultimately improving rankings and visibility.

Traditional search engines still hold value for straightforward searches and scenarios requiring exact matches. However, the future of search leans heavily towards semantic and vector-based approaches that prioritize meaning, context, and user satisfaction.

Integrating both methods or transitioning to semantic search engines can offer a significant competitive edge, meeting the expectations of modern users and adapting to evolving search trends.

‍